Jump to content
IGNORED

Jack vs. Tiger: Who's the Greatest Golfer?


sungho_kr

Greatest Golfer (GOAT)  

218 members have voted

  1. 1. Tiger or Jack: Who's the greatest golfer?

    • Tiger Woods is the man
      1629
    • Jack Nicklaus is my favorite
      817


Recommended Posts

Just finished reading Golfer's Greatest Championship The 1960 US Open in which Tommy Bolt was asked who was greater - Jack or Ben Hogan. His response was that Hogan. In support of his opinion he noted that he has seen Nicklaus watch Ben practice, but had never seen Ben watch anyone, what does that tell you.

That is the most nonsensical argument I've ever heard. Did Jack's desire to learn from a great elder make him less of a player somehow?

Link to comment
Share on other sites


I'm not quite old enough to have seen Jack in his prime, but I don't remember seeing highlights of him hitting some of the spectacular shots Tiger has made.  Can't remember the name of the tournament, but Tigers' 220+ yard 6-iron out of a fairway bunker over water to inside 6 feet has to be one of the best shots I've ever seen.  Just amazing!!  I'd have to side with Tiger.

In my titleist.gif Midsize Staff Bag...ALL titleist.gifcameron.gif See below
 sunmountain.gifMicro Cart gets me there & my bushnell.gif Tour V2 & GolfLogix tells me where I am.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites


If the "Greatest" is defined by most major wins there isn't any argument, it is Jack.  But if you think maybe it also has something to do with positive impact on the game in addition to being a great player,  I vote for Arnold.

Butch

Link to comment
Share on other sites



Using that criteria, I vote for Harry Vardon or maybe Old Tom Morris or Bobby Jones or Sam Snead or . . . Not sure really, but not the point of this discussion.

Originally Posted by ghalfaire

If the "Greatest" is defined by most major wins there isn't any argument, it is Jack.  But if you think maybe it also has something to do with positive impact on the game in addition to being a great player,  I vote for Arnold.


You should track that down. Other than the embellishment (inside 6-feet) it sounds eerily similar to a shot made at the Canadian Open, which finished up in the short rough over the green.

Originally Posted by RockingCPA

I'm not quite old enough to have seen Jack in his prime, but I don't remember seeing highlights of him hitting some of the spectacular shots Tiger has made.  Can't remember the name of the tournament, but Tigers' 220+ yard 6-iron out of a fairway bunker over water to inside 6 feet has to be one of the best shots I've ever seen.  Just amazing!!  I'd have to side with Tiger.

Mizuno MP600 driver, Cleveland '09 Launcher 3-wood, Callaway FTiz 18 degree hybrid, Cleveland TA1 3-9, Scratch SS8620 47, 53, 58, Cleveland Classic 2 mid-mallet, Bridgestone B330S, Sun Mountain four5.

Link to comment
Share on other sites




Originally Posted by RockingCPA

I'm not quite old enough to have seen Jack in his prime, but I don't remember seeing highlights of him hitting some of the spectacular shots Tiger has made.  Can't remember the name of the tournament, but Tigers' 220+ yard 6-iron out of a fairway bunker over water to inside 6 feet has to be one of the best shots I've ever seen.  Just amazing!!  I'd have to side with Tiger.


Well, I'm easily old enough to remember Nicklaus' prime - on the telly that is, never saw him in person.  He had a remarkably aggressive style, he really went after the ball in a way that was different from others in his day.  Some golfers today approach that explosive quality but still there isn't quite the same controlled abandon.  Maybe I'm just being nostalgic for black-and-white TV or something ....

Driver: Cobra 460SZ 9.0, med.
3 Wood: Taylor stiff
3-hybrid: Nike 18 deg stiff
4-hybrid:
Taylor RBZ 22 deg regular
Irons:5-9, Mizuno MP30, steel
Wedges: PW, 52, 56, 60 Mizuno MP30
Putter: Odyssey 2-ball

Link to comment
Share on other sites




Originally Posted by RockingCPA

I'm not quite old enough to have seen Jack in his prime, but I don't remember seeing highlights of him hitting some of the spectacular shots Tiger has made.  Can't remember the name of the tournament, but Tigers' 220+ yard 6-iron out of a fairway bunker over water to inside 6 feet has to be one of the best shots I've ever seen.  Just amazing!!  I'd have to side with Tiger.


Check out the 1 iron to the 17th in the 72 US Open, the final round at Turnberry in 1977(even though he lost to Tom Watson), the four rounds of the 1980 US Open, and the back nine at the final round of the 86 Masters, just to name a few.

Don

In the bag:

Driver: PING 410 Plus 9 degrees, Alta CB55 S  Fairway: Callaway Rogue 3W PX Even Flow Blue 6.0; Hybrid: Titleist 818H1 21* PX Even Flow Blue 6.0;  Irons: Titleist 718 AP1 5-W2(53*) Shafts- TT AMT Red S300 ; Wedges Vokey SM8 56-10D Putter: Scotty Cameron 2016 Newport 2.5  Ball: Titleist AVX or 2021 ProV1

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Tiger of course... He isnt done yet.

Plus I believe that the pedigree of golfers is better today than it was in Jack's time.

In my Ogio bag.

Titleist 910D2 driver, Adams irons & hybrid, Callaway wedges & a Nike Method putter.

And a yellow ball.
 

 

The great irony of life: "If nobody gets out alive, what's holding you back!?"

Link to comment
Share on other sites


As one being new to the game and watching it, I can say in the past I didn't really care for Tiger. As I began playing and watching the sport I began to enjoy and even want to catch Woods in a Tourny. I think he has shown he is human and that makes him more watchable and easy to route for.

  :sunmountain: eco lite stand Bag
:tmade: Sim 2 Max driver
 :callaway: Mavrick 20 * hybrid
:tmade: M2 3HL                               :mizuno: JPX 923 5-gw                           

 Lazrus 52, 56 wedges

:scotty_cameron:
:true_linkswear:-Lux Hybrid, Lux Sport, Original 1.2

:clicgear:

Link to comment
Share on other sites


  • 2 weeks later...

This thread is completely worthless if you leave out the likes of Bobby Jones and Ben Hogan!  Both, where taken from or walked away from the game in their prime and still are in the arguement...that in itself is amazing!

Link to comment
Share on other sites




Originally Posted by Bigtank

This thread is completely worthless if you leave out the likes of Bobby Jones and Ben Hogan!  Both, where taken from or walked away from the game in their prime and still are in the arguement...that in itself is amazing!


Actually, this thread is ONLY about Jack and Tiger.  If you look at the original post, it says "who is best, Jack or Tiger?"  not who is the greatest that ever lived.

I do agree with your thought though, that Jones and Hogan belong in the discussion of the greatest golfers, as do a few others.  Jones did retire in his prime at the tender age of 28, but Hogan probably played a little past his prime and retired when his game did not meet his exceptionally high standards.

Don

In the bag:

Driver: PING 410 Plus 9 degrees, Alta CB55 S  Fairway: Callaway Rogue 3W PX Even Flow Blue 6.0; Hybrid: Titleist 818H1 21* PX Even Flow Blue 6.0;  Irons: Titleist 718 AP1 5-W2(53*) Shafts- TT AMT Red S300 ; Wedges Vokey SM8 56-10D Putter: Scotty Cameron 2016 Newport 2.5  Ball: Titleist AVX or 2021 ProV1

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades



Originally Posted by dbuck

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bigtank

This thread is completely worthless if you leave out the likes of Bobby Jones and Ben Hogan!  Both, where taken from or walked away from the game in their prime and still are in the arguement...that in itself is amazing!

Actually, this thread is ONLY about Jack and Tiger.  If you look at the original post, it says "who is best, Jack or Tiger?"  not who is the greatest that ever lived.

I do agree with your thought though, that Jones and Hogan belong in the discussion of the greatest golfers, as do a few others.  Jones did retire in his prime at the tender age of 28, but Hogan probably played a little past his prime and retired when his game did not meet his exceptionally high standards.



Jones had health issues and a career outside his hobby of amateur golf. As an amateur, he obviously won't have the same resume as someone eligible for the PGA Championship and The Masters was still in the future. He retired from the sport having accomplished all he wanted to.

The same could be said for another great player who retired when he was only 1/2 way through what could have been the best record ever.

Byron Nelson.

Mizuno MP600 driver, Cleveland '09 Launcher 3-wood, Callaway FTiz 18 degree hybrid, Cleveland TA1 3-9, Scratch SS8620 47, 53, 58, Cleveland Classic 2 mid-mallet, Bridgestone B330S, Sun Mountain four5.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Tiger is the greatest because he brought the interest of golf to generations of people of all shapes, sizes and colours.  He also single handily raised the purse money of all tournamets around the wrold to levels that far exceed anything Jack experienced in his time.

Plus, at the age of 34, Tiger has 14 majors and Jack had 12 so in taoday's snapshot in time (age wise), Tiger has more majors.  Furhtermore, it is a safe assumption for all of us to agree that Tiger has atleast another 11 years of good golf which makes 4 more majors realistic for him.

Again, the level of greatness is the direct impact one player can bring to millions of people around the world who would've otherwise never payed attention.  Jordan did that in his time and Tiger has and will contiune to as well which IMO, makes him the greatest.

Heck, how many of us on this forum wouldn't be ON this forum if Tiger Woods never existed? I think a HUGE number of us wouldn't be talking golf if Tiger didn't motivate many of us to try the game and play because of the way he brought a sense of excitement and coolness to the game...and that is a stone hard fact.

Jack didn't have and never HAS HAD that effect.

Deryck Griffith

Titleist 910 D3: 9.5deg GD Tour AD DI7x | Nike Dymo 3W: 15deg, UST S-flex | Mizuno MP CLK Hybrid: 20deg, Project X Tour Issue 6.5, HC1 Shaft | Mizuno MP-57 4-PW, DG X100 Shaft, 1deg upright | Cleveland CG15 Wedges: 52, 56, 60deg | Scotty Cameron California Del Mar | TaylorMade Penta, TP Black LDP, Nike 20XI-X

Link to comment
Share on other sites




Originally Posted by Deryck Griffith

Tiger is the greatest because he brought the interest of golf to generations of people of all shapes, sizes and colours.  He also single handily raised the purse money of all tournamets around the wrold to levels that far exceed anything Jack experienced in his time.

Plus, at the age of 34, Tiger has 14 majors and Jack had 12 so in taoday's snapshot in time (age wise), Tiger has more majors.  Furhtermore, it is a safe assumption for all of us to agree that Tiger has atleast another 11 years of good golf which makes 4 more majors realistic for him.

Again, the level of greatness is the direct impact one player can bring to millions of people around the world who would've otherwise never payed attention.  Jordan did that in his time and Tiger has and will contiune to as well which IMO, makes him the greatest.

Heck, how many of us on this forum wouldn't be ON this forum if Tiger Woods never existed? I think a HUGE number of us wouldn't be talking golf if Tiger didn't motivate many of us to try the game and play because of the way he brought a sense of excitement and coolness to the game...and that is a stone hard fact.

Jack didn't have and never HAS HAD that effect.


You had me up until the last sentence.  Not only is that incorrect, but he influenced many people including this kid from California that had posted all of his stats and records in his bedroom so he could emulate his career and possibly even eclipse it.  I remember my brother's set of MacGregor Golden Bears and how they were so cool.  Your points about Tiger and Michael Jordan are valid, but you have to remember that the marketing machinery (namely Nike) didn't really come out until after Jack's prime.  Jordan, back in '84 was the first real "world-wide phenomena" that I can recall.  Of course the old-timers will argue that Arnold had a serious influence on the game as he was the first real star of the television era.  Now I am not saying that Jack would be as far reaching as Tiger (I don't think so!), but to say he hasn't had that effect is not true.

Cobra LTDx 10.5* | Big Tour 15.5*| Rad Tour 18.5*  | Titleist U500 4-23* | T100 5-P | Vokey SM7 50/8* F, 54/10* S, SM8 58/10* S | Scotty Cameron Squareback No. 1 | Vice Pro Plus  

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Originally Posted by TourSpoon

You had me up until the last sentence.  Not only is that incorrect, but he influenced many people including this kid from California that had posted all of his stats and records in his bedroom so he could emulate his career and possibly even eclipse it.  I remember my brother's set of MacGregor Golden Bears and how they were so cool.  Your points about Tiger and Michael Jordan are valid, but you have to remember that the marketing machinery (namely Nike) didn't really come out until after Jack's prime.  Jordan, back in '84 was the first real "world-wide phenomena" that I can recall.  Of course the old-timers will argue that Arnold had a serious influence on the game as he was the first real star of the television era.  Now I am not saying that Jack would be as far reaching as Tiger (I don't think so!), but to say he hasn't had that effect is not true.


You make good points.  Heck, Jack influenced Tiger which is the ironic thing so I certainly agree with you.

As it pertains to Nike, yes, Jack didn't benefit from that type of marketing machine.  With Tiger though, the fact that he looked "different" in a sport that was primarily ruled by the american, british elite really brought masses to the game around the world who never dreamed of having the chance at playing such a "rich man's sport."  That pressure with the pressure to perform consistently and live up to the hope of many in front of "everyone," media, fans, agents, sponors, etc, etc as a person that looked different is what really adds to why I think he's greatest.  In fact, I think all of the pressure to perform under those circumstances is what eventually caused him to moraly break down and do the stupid things he did which he has paid for in a BIG way this year.  I'm glad he paid for it because personly, getting caught I think is the best thing that has happened to him.  We'll see if he can continue to live up to being the greatest.

Deryck Griffith

Titleist 910 D3: 9.5deg GD Tour AD DI7x | Nike Dymo 3W: 15deg, UST S-flex | Mizuno MP CLK Hybrid: 20deg, Project X Tour Issue 6.5, HC1 Shaft | Mizuno MP-57 4-PW, DG X100 Shaft, 1deg upright | Cleveland CG15 Wedges: 52, 56, 60deg | Scotty Cameron California Del Mar | TaylorMade Penta, TP Black LDP, Nike 20XI-X

Link to comment
Share on other sites


I think to say that he's pulling people into the sport and singlehandedly raised purses is rather debatable. Even if he does (did) draw new people to the game, who cares?

Is Taylor Swift a better artist than Joan Armatrading or Nancy Wilson because she makes more little girls want to pretend to play the guitar and sing? (That her music is completely awful is irrelevant).

Mizuno MP600 driver, Cleveland '09 Launcher 3-wood, Callaway FTiz 18 degree hybrid, Cleveland TA1 3-9, Scratch SS8620 47, 53, 58, Cleveland Classic 2 mid-mallet, Bridgestone B330S, Sun Mountain four5.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Originally Posted by Deryck Griffith

You make good points.  Heck, Jack influenced Tiger which is the ironic thing so I certainly agree with you.

As it pertains to Nike, yes, Jack didn't benefit from that type of marketing machine.  With Tiger though, the fact that he looked "different" in a sport that was primarily ruled by the american, british elite really brought masses to the game around the world who never dreamed of having the chance at playing such a "rich man's sport."  That pressure with the pressure to perform consistently and live up to the hope of many in front of "everyone," media, fans, agents, sponors, etc, etc as a person that looked different is what really adds to why I think he's greatest.  In fact, I think all of the pressure to perform under those circumstances is what eventually caused him to moraly break down and do the stupid things he did which he has paid for in a BIG way this year.  I'm glad he paid for it because personly, getting caught I think is the best thing that has happened to him.  We'll see if he can continue to live up to being the greatest.

Do you think the pressure was from performing under those circumstances or could it be from his father's "How to Raise a Tiger" approach to creating a prodigy?  Probably a combination of everything.  I don't think the human psyche is programmed to be able to handle such a roller coaster ride.

I do have to give the edge as far as greatest golfer to Jack with the full understanding that Tiger has all the gifts to become the greatest.  IMO, time will tell.  Every golfer has had their obstacles to overcome and it will be interesting to see how it all plays out.  I have seen Tiger blister it at Doral and have witnessed Jack on the Senior Tour at PGA National just be a surgeon.  Both are legends and I have been lucky enough to have seen both play great golf in person.

Cobra LTDx 10.5* | Big Tour 15.5*| Rad Tour 18.5*  | Titleist U500 4-23* | T100 5-P | Vokey SM7 50/8* F, 54/10* S, SM8 58/10* S | Scotty Cameron Squareback No. 1 | Vice Pro Plus  

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • TST Partners

    TourStriker PlaneMate
    Golfer's Journal
    ShotScope
    The Stack System
    FlightScope Mevo
    Direct: Mevo, Mevo+, and Pro Package.

    Coupon Codes (save 10-15%): "IACAS" for Mevo/Stack, "IACASPLUS" for Mevo+/Pro Package, and "THESANDTRAP" for ShotScope.
  • Posts

    • I had to think about this topic for a while. I don't tend to remember specific details about my putts, but a few do stand out in my mind so I guess they're worth noting. I don't know that I'd call them my favorite but it's close enough. #18 at Spooky Brook Might be the hardest 4' putt I've ever had. Pin was back right and I hit my third shot just to the right of it. The green slopes fairly severely back to front. I read the green but I knew the putt anyway as I've seen it before. I told the guys I was playing with that the putt was it was going to break almost 3' and if it doesn't go in I'd have a longer coming back up for par than I was looking at. It went in. #12 at Quail Brook I'm not even sure how to describe this green properly. It's not quite a two-tiered green, but the back and front are separated by a ridge that goes across the middle of it, with the green sloping harder off the front than the back. You can generally putt from the front to a back hole location but good luck keeping the ball on the green if you putt from back to front. On this particular day, I was looking at the latter. I had to putt up into the apron due to how the ball was going to break and that helped slow the ball down enough to hit the hole at the perfect speed. One of the rare birdies I've seen on that hole. #2 at Hyatt Hills Short par 5. This makes the list because it's the first eagle putt I've ever made, which funny enough happened the day after the first eagle I've ever made. I've made two eagles in all my life and they came on back to back days. I wasn't even planning on playing golf - it was a Monday - but I was doing some work at the place I used to work at when I was younger and catching up with some of the guys I've known for years. They were going out to play in the afternoon and had a spot available. I used to see these guys every day for years but we've never played together, so I said I'm in. I hit a really good approach shot into slope that separated the two tiers on the green and spun the ball closer to the hole. Had roughly 8' left to the hole, a downhill right to left breaker. One of the guys said, "You've got to make this, I've never seen an eagle before," and I said, "I've never made an eagle putt before." And then I made it. #17 at Stoneleigh @GolfLug's post reminded me of my own heroics on #17 a couple of years ago. The hole was back left, in the bottom tier. I hit my approach short of the green and flubbed my chip so it stayed on the top tier. I read how the putt was going to break after the ramp (is that what you call it?), then read my putt up to that point. It needed to basically die at that point because if it hit the slope with any kind of speed, it would long past the hole and possibly off the green. I hit the putt perfectly and holed the 40-footer center cup. #6 at Meadow at Neshanic Valley, #15 in the Round This was during the stroke play qualifier of my tournament. It might be a little bit of recency bias and I hit some really good long putts in the four rounds I played, but this 7-footer was my favorite putt of the entire tournament. The hole was cut on the top of a ridge. I hit my tee shot short right but hit a pretty good chip just long and below the hole. Play had backed up at this point, with the ladies waiting on the tee while we were finishing up. I hit the putt just a hair on the high side and it curled around the hole, fell back a couple of inches and stopped on lip. We all looked at it incredulously, "How does that not fall in?" Before I took my first step towards the hole, the ball must have thought the same thing and decided to drop.
    • I don't remember a ton of putts, but I've thought about this a bit and came up with 2 good ones. #5 at Mid-South: 2017 Newport Cup I remember the putt pretty well, but the surrounding details are a little hazy. I believe this was in my singles match against @cipher, and it was a hole he was stroking on. I had hit a mediocre approach to the front of the green and had what must have been a 50 foot putt to a back pin. If I remember correctly, @cipher was pretty close for an easy par at worst. I had @mvmac help me out with a read, which ended up being a great read by him. Hit the putt and jarred it for birdie. It was perfect speed, too, would have been an easy 2 putt if it hadn't gone in. I think we ended up tying for the hole. But I rarely make putts that long, and doing it to steal half a hole was really nice. #3 Fox Hollow (Links): 2023 Match Play This was on the third extra hole of a scratch match against a legitimate 0 handicapper. We had tied after 18 holes and traded pars on the first two extra holes. On the third extra hole, he had about 30 feet for birdie; I had about 25. We were on pretty much the exact same line. He missed his putt just on the low side, and I conceded the par. I felt good over this putt - I knew the break well and just needed good speed. I hit a great (not perfect) putt, and BAM, back of the cup for the victory on the 21st hole. I will say that the speed wasn't great, as it would have been a few feet past if it didn't hit the cup. But I wanted to give the ball a chance and take a bit of break out of it. I went on to win the match play tournament, which is my only tournament victory in a scratch event.
    • there will be lots of changes.  i mean, look at newey past, each team fell off a cliff when he moved on i think max is the magic bullet   if red bull loses him then whee are they going for drivers?   lots of young talent but he is a proven winner and i’m sure top engineers love to work with him  
    • I too, like @GolfLug, remember great wedge, iron shots, or my missed putts, more than my made putts. My most memorable recently, would be: #17 Old Course St. Andrews (last year) I had been putting awful all day (I started 3 putt, 4 putt, 3 putt, 3 putt), but found a putting stroke on the back 9 and was 1 under on the back going into 16 and of course I 3-putted it for a bogey. Got to 17 and my playing partner just hit it into the hotel, so I went a little more left and decided to not try and hit it over the hotel.  And as soon as my ball was in the air, I heard one of the other caddies do the chicken noise.  LOL My shot was a little more left than I wanted, about 185 yards, I hit a 6-iron and it was drawing right at the flag.  The pin was just to the right of he bunker and towards the front of the green. My ball hit short (and just missed going into said bunker) and stopped about 15 feet left of the hole. Had a little left to right break and as soon as I hit it, I knew it was in.  Birdie on the road hole, looked at the caddie and said not bad for a Chicken.  Parred 18 (missed 10 foot birdie putt) for a 35 on the back 9 at the Old Course. #18 Springfield G&CC Last year while playing in our season long match play event, my partner and I get the 18th hole needing to win the match to move on into the knockout round.  We are tied going into 18.  A tie and we lose on overall points by .5.  Our teaching pro is on the other team (very good golfer), so we were pretty sure we needed a birdie to have a chance to win the match, I hit on of the best drives I hit all day and had about 135 yards to the pin, but it was in a place where you didn't really want to be long.  So I hit a PW and it landed just short of the flag but released about 12 feet past the hole, so have a devilish putt coming back down the hill.  Our competitors were away and the pro missed his birdie putt by inches, I thought it was in when he hit it.  So after reading the putt, which probably had a 2 cup left to right break, I made the putt to win the match.   #15 Springfield G&CC A few years back, was playing in the first round of the Club Championship (against the previous years runner-up) and my putter was balky all day.  Got to the 15 hole, 2nd Par 5 on back, and was 3-down with 4 to play.  We both hit good drives, both hit good second shots and we both hit decent 3rd shots.  I was about 15 feet and he was just a hair longer.  He missed his putt, I had another slider putt down the hill, with about a foot of right to left break and made the putt.  I birded the next hole, to go 1 down, but not a memorable putt as I only needed a bogey to beat him on that hole, he had all kinds of issues going on.  Lost on 17, as he birdied it, right after I missed mine to lose 2&1.
    • Wordle 1,049 3/6* ⬜⬜⬜🟩🟨 ⬜⬜🟨🟩⬜ 🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩  
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...