• Announcements

    • iacas

      Introducing TST "Clubs!"   08/28/2017

      No, we're not getting into the equipment business, but we do have "clubs" here on TST now. Groups. Check them out here:
Sign in to follow this  
RRLavigne

Golf lessons - Do you take them?

0  

  1. 1. do you or have you taken formal golf lessons?

    • Yes
      52
    • No
      21


Recommended Posts

RRLavigne    1

I just took my 1st formal golf lesson and already learned a lot about what I've been doing wrong in my swing. I'm wondering how many on this forum take or took lessons and how many just do their thing? Please chime in.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sign up (or log in) today! It's free (and you won't see this ad anymore)!

Sign up (or log in) today! It's free (and you won't see this ad anymore)!

onephenom    10
I used to take lessons.... but he had no idea how to explain anything about the swing. He had a good swing but no idea how to explain it. Didn't know how to explaining what clearing the hips means... just told me to do it. Didn't know ball flight laws (the real ones) I wish you had to show a teaching ability before becoming a PGA pro

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

RRLavigne    1
Originally Posted by onephenom

I used to take lessons.... but he had no idea how to explain anything about the swing. He had a good swing but no idea how to explain it. Didn't know how to explaining what clearing the hips means... just told me to do it. Didn't know ball flight laws (the real ones)

I wish you had to show a teaching ability before becoming a PGA pro

Wow, how can you be a PGA pro and not know how and why things happen in golf and not be able to explain it? The guy i went too seemd to be able to explain everything including questions about things we haven't gotten to yet in the lessons. Gave me a few exercises to help me with the fundamentals and set up (I'm a beginner) and explained exactly WHY the exercises will help my swing. He also explained exactly why I seem to be able to hit decent with my irons and not my driver ,,, made perfect sense once he explained it. I'm really looking forward to my next lesson.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

MS256    145
Originally Posted by RRLavigne

Wow, how can you be a PGA pro and not know how and why things happen in golf and not be able to explain it? The guy i went too seemd to be able to explain everything including questions about things we haven't gotten to yet in the lessons. Gave me a few exercises to help me with the fundamentals and set up (I'm a beginner) and explained exactly WHY the exercises will help my swing. He also explained exactly why I seem to be able to hit decent with my irons and not my driver ,,, made perfect sense once he explained it. I'm really looking forward to my next lesson.

Because they could pass the PAT, pass the written tests, and put in the hours as an apprentice but aren't good at teaching.

May even have a totally different idea of what is "correct" than another golf pro down the road and neither one is wrong...Just different.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

jamo    703
Because they could pass the PAT, pass the written tests, and put in the hours as an apprentice but aren't good at teaching. May even have a totally different idea of what is "correct" than another golf pro down the road and neither one is wrong...Just different.

Also, you don't have to be a PGA pro to teach golf. You just can't claim to be a PGA pro, use their name/logo in promotional material, stuff like that. But you can still teach golf, call yourself a "golf pro" or "teaching pro" or whatever.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

RRLavigne    1

Actually the place I'm going for lessons is owned by a PGA pro however the owner not the person who's personally teaching me. Come to think of it I have no idea if my actual teacher is a PGA pro, he may simply be an experienced teacher who works for one. That said I think he's a good teacher so regardless, as a beginner I know he can help me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ColeMc    0

I've recently started getting lessons and couldn't be happier with them.  I played when I was a kid and was taught by my Dad, but haven't played properly in years. When I decided to get back into it I thought  it would be pretty beneficial to get some lessons early on, work the kinks out and get rid of any bad habits that I'd picked up before they became truly ingrained.

Luckily, the bloke I'm taking lessons from knows what he's talking about and is really good at getting things across and explaining stuff.

Lessons are of course a luxury that not every one can afford, especially on a regular basis.  But I'd defo recommend a lesson(s) to people like me trying to get the fundamentals right, it's only gonna pay off in the long run!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

jetsknicks1    60

Took lessons twice. Once when I was just starting and they helped a ton, took 8/10 strokes off my average. I just finished a set of 4 lessons and the results so far, have been kinda hit & miss. The pro was awesome, got his points across and did a great job of explaining what I was doing wrong & how to fix it. The issue for me, is lack of practice time and therefore, having trouble making the new swing repeatable. Last week is a perfect example. I played "Ok" on the front and had 3 pars & a birdie on the back but also had a stretch of 3 holes that I played in 8 over.

Practice, practice, practice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Originally Posted by onephenom

I used to take lessons.... but he had no idea how to explain anything about the swing. He had a good swing but no idea how to explain it. Didn't know how to explaining what clearing the hips means... just told me to do it. Didn't know ball flight laws (the real ones)

I wish you had to show a teaching ability before becoming a PGA pro

I live in Lafayette.  I'd be curious who you used to make sure I don't make the same mistake with my wife.  If you are not comfortable throwing a name out there please message me or at least give the course name since they often have several instructors.  Thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

YnotMcFly    0
I took a few lessons a couple years ago and really enjoyed them. Then unfortunately I took last year off when life got in the way, but the good news is that I just had a lesson yesterday and plan on continuing with several more this season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'v thought about taking lessons since I really got into golf 18 months ago, but never got round to sorting it

I'v mainly tried to teach myself using this wonderful thing (internet / forums) and I shoot 83 - 89 95% of the time.

Anyone got their first lesson/s after they have already improved beyond a beginner / major hacker?

Pretty sure I have a few fundamental swing problems though, which crop up a little too often to shoot sub 80.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

MS256    145

No...And one of the worst things happened to me that could have happened.

I was good at hitting the ball the wrong way from day one. Gave me very little incentive to try to develop a fundamentally sound golf swing. It was great at first because I was pretty good without having to go through the normal learning process but it was bad because once I reached a peak there was very little chance of improvement other than improving my short game and the normal course management details.

Tried to change some things at various times but always jumped back into my same old flawed swing as soon as something wasn't going well.

Still stuck at shooting between 70 and 80 most of the time, depending on the course and how well I'm playing...And I've been stuck in that same place for a long time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Jmdmbike    29
I've taken lessons a few times and found them helpful. Just finished a series of 5 lessons in March. I've got a better understanding of my swing and what I'm doing wrong when I hit mediocre and bad shots and what I'm doing right when I hit good shots. The pro I've taken lessons from is good at keeping things straightforward and keeping the change process as simple as possible, which is key because change is tough when it doesn't immediately feel natural. As said in an earlier post, practice is key. I'll probably go in for a "tune-up" sometime during the season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

boogielicious    1,159

I went to a local guy, but had a similar experience as the OP.  I didn't like the lesson because he couldn't tell me why I should be doing what he suggested.  I was frustrated.  Then I read a lot of material on the golf swing and found this forum.  Using this knowledge helped me understand what I wanted in an instructor.

I went to clinic with Dave, James and Erik in the Boston area, which was much better than my first lesson because they explained why the swing works the way it does and what I could do to improve.  It was a S&T; clinic, but they really focused on parts of it and not all of the S&T; methodology.  Then I took Evolvr lessons, which helped even more.

I think it is important to find a good instructor.  But I also feel that it is important for you to be a good student as well if you really want to improve.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Rick Martin    53

Self taught, then took lessons after about 3-4 yrs of playing. I have a huge video and VHS library of instruction and can remember my Dad and I videotaping our swings (back in the 80s).....but now I can't see anyone trying to pick up the game without taking lessons on a regular basis. But the best way to get good is finding a competitive group and playing for money and entering tournaments.

As a gift to myself for leaving the Army, I rewarded myself with a trip to the David Leadbetter Golf  Academy after playing the game about 20+ yrs.  Former pro Bob Lohr was my instructor. Video analysis of full swing. Came back the next year for short game with another instructor. Helped me get back on track.

Saw a local guy for reinforcement. He's helped.

But my biggest help has been long distance with pro Zach Allen (zachallengolf.com, $19/video analysis) (you might have seen some of his articles on Golf Tips Magazine). I've sent in 2-3 full swing videos and he's really helped by making some adjustments to my grip and takeaway. Still working on it, but he's helped my game to a point where I enjoy going to play again.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

David in FL    1,528

Nope.

I've never even seen my swing on video, though I've been told that I look like I'm trying to kill a snake with a stick.  One of these days I'll grow a big enough pair to do a video and post it here.....just for the entertainment that it will likely provide.

I imagine that a session with me could make Erik or Mike seriously consider giving up teaching!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2017 TST Partners

    Talamore Golf Resort
    PING Golf
    FlightScope Mevo
    Mission Belt
    Snell Golf
    Frogger Golf
    PitchFix USA
  • Popular Now

  • Posts

    • I read about 7 pages of the comments on this interesting topics, but not all (yet), so forgive me if I am duplicating something already said. I voted that physical is most important to golf and I agree that it is most important by far. But,what good players view as physical, and I don't blame them for viewing this as such, can also largely be a mental issue for less skilled players. Things that are automatic for some, are not yet so for others and they need to think about those first, or they don't have a chance... I won't compare a player to another one, but instead one player (namely me) at different times, yet in similar conditions. * Can someone tell me why I shot 75 and 111 less than a week apart (the 111 was on a more difficult course but still... it was the highest score in probably 8-10 years for me)? I was the same guy with the same physical abilities, but I made really poor choices, compounded errors with more errors and in the process lost the swing completely: shanks, tops, thins, etc... The silver lining was putting which is and remained my strength, even on that day...  * Can someone tell me why the first time my name was called on a tee box in an official Norcal (NCGA) tournament, I was shaking so badly, I nearly whiffed my drive which ended in a terrible spot, causing me to re-tee? It's some form of pressure, one I was totally unfamiliar with and which no longer affects me that badly. However, even at the highest level in golf, think Ryder Cup, the first tee shot is the most nerve wracking shot, for most people. You might say pressure is physical (tension, shaking, sweating, etc...), but it is controlled by the mind and by experience, so one can train for it, to some extent: breathing exercises, putting drills that force you to hole out x shots in a row or you start from scratch, playing worst ball with oneself, for example... * Can someone tell me why in casual rounds and less so in competitive rounds, I sometimes forget my pre-shot routine and don't put myself behind the ball and then step in, but rather just step in and hit a great shot, 10 degrees offline to the left? Lack of focus and/or discipline, which is a mental error, leading to a physical one (being lined up wrong) * Can someone tell me why, all of sudden, I completely lost any ability I previously had to hit fairway woods (there is another thread in "Instruction and Playing Tips" about this? I think I finally got it back, and while the practical cause is physical, the real root of the problem is mental. Not checking the ball position, hanging back because of it and losing balance (to my heels) in the process. All physical problems that can be overcome by an assertive mind. Also, what about the power of visualization? Look at Jason Day actively and consciously closing his eyes prior to any swing. Also, do you see in your mind the line a well struck putt is going to take? I do, and unless my read is completely off (it happens once in a while, or the putt flattens at the hole and I didn't read that), for the most part that's what happens. There is no doubt that our conscious and unconscious mind drives all physical activity and perhaps we qualify everything unconscious as physical and the swing certainly is too fast to consciously drive it in its minute details, but the conscious mind also has a role in controlling the outcome. YMMV.
    • Sir Charles can swing this way now too. .his mental game is so strong he doesn't need both hands. (sorry ... couldn't help it)
    • A friend is planning, I think he's booked us at the Duck's in Aberlady.  I know its a small village, but do you have any comments?  
    • Completely stupid point worth (unfortunately) less than the time I spent replying. The physical skills to do so.
    • I may not be  expert on the courses (yet) but when it comes to pubs I'm your man!
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Blog Entries

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. CoachB25
      CoachB25
      (60 years old)
    2. Fsgolfer
      Fsgolfer
      (61 years old)
    3. Zach
      Zach
      (27 years old)
  • Get Great Gear with Amazon