Followers 0

# What's Fairest?

## 17 posts in this topic

2 Situations-

1. Mystery Holes Net Computation- 9 Mystery Holes are picked at random after the completion of an 18 hole round.  How would you compute NET SCORE?

a.  Half of each Players Handicap.

b.  Strokes as they fall (i.e. an 18 capper would always get 9 shots, but a 9 capper could get as few as 0 and as many as 9 depending on which handicap holes were selected.

c.  Something else.

2.  A " Closest to the Hole " Proxy was mistakenly set up by a green on a short par 5 without any specification of whether it was closest 2nd, 3rd or any shot from off the green.  The first name on the board marked "in 2" by his name, but the name after did not (and likely was in a scramble group that didn't reach the green in 2).  A subsequent player's 2nd shot comes to rest 2 inches outside the player who likely was there in 3.  How would you determine winner?

0

##### Share on other sites

42? Is the answer 42? I think it is but I'm not entirely sure I'm following the post. You know what? I think it's 42 and I'm sticking to that.
0

##### Share on other sites

Half the players handicap in response to your question 1. No idea in response to your question 2. Sounds like whoever set that competition up screwed up pretty good.
0

##### Share on other sites

2 Situations- 1. Mystery Holes Net Computation- 9 Mystery Holes are picked at random after the completion of an 18 hole round.  How would you compute NET SCORE? a.  Half of each Players Handicap. b.  Strokes as they fall (i.e. an 18 capper would always get 9 shots, but a 9 capper could get as few as 0 and as many as 9 depending on which handicap holes were selected. c.  Something else. 2.  A " Closest to the Hole " Proxy was mistakenly set up by a green on a short par 5 without any specification of whether it was closest 2nd, 3rd or any shot from off the green.  The first name on the board marked "in 2" by his name, but the name after did not (and likely was in a scramble group that didn't reach the green in 2).  A subsequent player's 2nd shot comes to rest 2 inches outside the player who likely was there in 3.  How would you determine winner?

I agree.

0

##### Share on other sites

42? Is the answer 42? I think it is but I'm not entirely sure I'm following the post. You know what? I think it's 42 and I'm sticking to that.

Bennie's corollary: "What's 6 times 7?" :-D

0

Snow White.
0

##### Share on other sites

Well, I dunno, but I used to have one. It was purple and then the wheels fell off. Damn shame, those peaches were ripe! Four stones to a windmill!

0

##### Share on other sites

Half the players handicap in response to your question 1.

No idea in response to your question 2. Sounds like whoever set that competition up screwed up pretty good.

Agreed on both counts. "b" is like winning a lottery. It has as much luck as skill.

0

##### Share on other sites

The guy that decided to put the "closest to the hole" contest on a par 5 should be forced to buy everybody a prize. ;-)
0

##### Share on other sites

The guy that decided to put the "closest to the hole" contest on a par 5 should be forced to buy everybody a prize.

I was going to say...this is one of many good reasons to do your closest to the pin on a par 3.

0

##### Share on other sites

2 Situations- 1. Mystery Holes Net Computation- 9 Mystery Holes are picked at random after the completion of an 18 hole round.  How would you compute NET SCORE? a.  Half of each Players Handicap. b.  Strokes as they fall (i.e. an 18 capper would always get 9 shots, but a 9 capper could get as few as 0 and as many as 9 depending on which handicap holes were selected. c.  Something else. 2.  A " Closest to the Hole " Proxy was mistakenly set up by a green on a short par 5 without any specification of whether it was closest 2nd, 3rd or any shot from off the green.  The first name on the board marked "in 2" by his name, but the name after did not (and likely was in a scramble group that didn't reach the green in 2).  A subsequent player's 2nd shot comes to rest 2 inches outside the player who likely was there in 3. How would you determine winner?

Flip a quarter?

0

##### Share on other sites

The concept of "fair" has no place in the game of golf!
0

##### Share on other sites

Snow White.

I am such an idiot!!!

I just realized how clever you are.

0

##### Share on other sites

I am such an idiot!!!

I just realized how clever you are.

Lol. Take your time GD, we'll wait for you.

0

##### Share on other sites

I am such an idiot!!!

I just realized how clever you are.

I see the humor in the Snow White reference, but have you figured out the humor in "42"?

The guy that decided to put the "closest to the hole" contest on a par 5 should be forced to buy everybody a prize.

The gal who does it was considering giving everyone a (likely small) prize or just drawing names from everyone on the list.

0

##### Share on other sites

I see the humor in the Snow White reference, but have you figured out the humor in "42"?

The gal who does it was considering giving everyone a (likely small) prize or just drawing names from everyone on the list.

I assumed it was a reference to "Hitchhikers Guide. . ." Douglas Adams.

That makes the most sense for the solution to item 2.

0

##### Share on other sites

I assumed it was a reference to "Hitchhikers Guide. . ." Douglas Adams.

DON'T PANIC.

0

## Create an account

Register a new account

Followers 0

• ### Topics Being Discussed Right Now on The Sand Trap

• #### My Swing (PumaAttack)

By pumaAttack, in Member Swings

• 128 replies
• 3,614 views
• #### What do you HATE the most about golf?

By stolpioni, in Golf Talk

• 58 replies
• 822 views
• #### GPS, WHY ?

By paininthenuts, in Golf Talk

• 28 replies
• 439 views
• #### Rory McIlroy is overrated...

By senorchipotle, in Tour Talk

• 329 replies
• 28,413 views
• #### Playing a Round of Golf Solo

By boil3rmak3r, in Golf Talk

• 250 replies
• 4,964 views

• Want to join this community?

We'd love to have you!

• ## 2016 TST Partners

• ### Posts

• Rory McIlroy is overrated...
Ha ha ha.. In my defense I think it was a very heavily veiled reference.
• My Swing (PumaAttack)
Gotcha. Is OTT with the club head and not the arms/hands then?  As in if you get your hands out but keep the club head behind you its ok?
• What do you HATE the most about golf?
It had been a while since I had been reminded of this. Yesterday, I was in a slow foursome behind an even-slower foursome. My guys took forever, but we still were waiting on the group in front of us. Five-flipping hour round. Shot a 45 on the front and then 52 on the back after the driver went sideways. Just too much time in the hot sun.
• My Swing (PumaAttack)
Shifting the arms out helps shallow the club. Unless you're bad. Then it can lead to OTT.
• GPS, WHY ?
Yes I believe we are in agreement.  What I like the most is this part you wrote: "I'm going to try and play the shot with the highest potential chance of success".  I use to play a lot of poker and accordingly had to get very comfortable with the related probability math.  As such I see the highest potential chance of success from that angle.  Sometimes the outcome from a probability perspective is better when one takes a risk.  And, I believe we are in agreement on all of this. Reading between the lines in LSW, I believe @iacas looks at things from a probability perspective (even though he didn't risk boring many readers with the details of the related math).

• ### Today's Birthdays

No users celebrating today