Jump to content
Note:Β This thread is 2102 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic.Β Thank you!

Unknown Penalties  

74 members have voted

  1. 1. Read the first post, and answer this: Do you support the lack of any additional penalty strokes for penalties "unknown" to players, despite their responsibility to know, follow, and apply the Rules of Golf?

    • Yes, the USGA/R&A are right to reward ignorance and dishonesty.
      11
    • No, players are responsible for knowing the Rules of Golf, and are now being incentivized to be ignorant and/or dishonest.
      63


Recommended Posts

It's definitely not an improvement.

Gives guys the chance to be like the mafia on the witness stand. You know, plead the fifth.

"I don't know nothing about no penalty." - Sorry. I just watched a show on Santo Trafficante and the actor was hilarious.

Β 

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

1 hour ago, iacas said:

Suppose someone drops in a wrong place (not a serious breach), and doesn't think anything of it at all. They breached the rules, unknowingly, and you say "think about every drop you took." They say "Yeah I did, I'm good." That doesn't invalidate the exception. It's still an unknown penalty.

That person who drops in the wrong place is losing out because they didn't know the rules. They are incentivized to learn the rules because they caught a penalty for playing from the wrong place (assuming they were caught). They can't have gained an advantage for playing from that wrong place, or they'd have got the DQ penalty anyway (serious breach). Thus, they have paid at least something for their mistake. I'm not too concerned about that person.

You mentioned people who hit it in a water hazard and just don't count the penalty stroke. That's the person I'm trying to hoover up. If they say yes they took a drop for hitting it in the water, then I would ask them if they included the penalty stroke. If they said they had, then I'm good. If they said they hadn't, then I would make sure they added it. They've learned something and no one loses anything.Β 

I get that you're upset that this incentivizes people to not know the rules. I agree with you. It doesn't mean that we just have to fall back and say "well f*#& it there's nothing we can do". There are things we can do. Like this.

From my perspective, I never thought of the penalty for signing for a wrong score as being to incentivize people to learn the rules. You sign your scorecard and hand it in, what you're doing is saying to everyone else in the event "here is my score, I am confirming that it is correct and you can rely on it". If someone else sees your score, finds out that they are 1 back with 1 hole to go, they may change the way they play that hole from if you had written down the correct score. The DQ penalty was to fix that. The 2 strokes was also kind of to fix that. Now you're no longer having to make that promise. As I think about it, I think that with the old rules, you had an incentive to ask about a potential penalty when you finished your round. If you didn't and it came up you'd get DQ'd or another 2 strokes. Now, you have no such incentive because why bring it up? That's I guess why I think there is value in asking people if anything came up about which they are not sure. I like to think that most people will do the right thing in that situation.

What really annoys me about this change is it seems like it's there purely because the perception is that Lexi Thompson got 4 penalty strokes for moving her ball an inch. I have never marked a ball and picked it up without knowing where I had to put it to put it back where I picked it up from. The fact that she wasn't able to do that and that has apparently resulted in this rule change makes my blood boil.

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

  • Administrator
44 minutes ago, Ty_Webb said:

That person who drops in the wrong place is losing out because they didn't know the rules.

Maybe the wrong place they dropped is a better lie, and they only "lose out" if they're found out.

44 minutes ago, Ty_Webb said:

They are incentivized to learn the rules because they caught a penalty for playing from the wrong place (assuming they were caught).

And they'd be further incentivized if they got four shots instead of two.

44 minutes ago, Ty_Webb said:

They can't have gained an advantage for playing from that wrong place, or they'd have got the DQ penalty anyway (serious breach).

Sure they could have. Say they dropped in the fairway instead of in the first cut. Or maybe they dropped in a thinner lie in the rough instead of a juicy thick spot within the drop area.Β Neither of those areΒ a serious breach and thus not a DQ-able offense.

Statements like that make me unsure how well you know the topic material.


You keep going off on these weird tangents. I feel like I keep talking past you, and you likely feel the same.

The points I've tried to make, and which nobody has persuaded me otherwise, is that the rules change incentivizes ignorance, feigned or authentic. It encourages players to remain mum about a possible rules infraction because when they inquire, they can no longer use the exception and claim it was "unknown."

Let's say you're a kid with an allowance. You like candy bars, and they change the laws to say that if you're caught stealing a candy bar, but profess not to know that it was "wrong," you only pay the price of the candy bar.

If you're really into candy bars, enough that it over-rides your morality or whatever, what are you gonna do? You're gonna steal candy bars! You might steal 10 candy bars, and even if you get caught nine times, at nine different stores, you've come out ahead.

It's the added penalty - often you have to pay a fine, something goes on your record, your parents are called down to the police station… etc. that makes stealing unattractive.

Now, that situation really only parallelsΒ the intentional cheater, but those exist, too, and this rule is great for them. After all, they've already incurred a penalty - this rules change lets them try to get away with it with no risk at all.Β Worst case, they get the penalty they incurred.

44 minutes ago, Ty_Webb said:

I get that you're upset that this incentivizes people to not know the rules. I agree with you. It doesn't mean that we just have to fall back and say "well f*#& it there's nothing we can do". There are things we can do. Like this.

I don't care about people you're trying to "hoover up." It's not going to work like you seem to think, because someone saying "I'm certain I didn't break any rules" doesn't invalidate the exception. You could immediately say "what about that drop in the wrong place on #4?" and if they say "I didn't know that was a penalty" they still get to use that exception.

44 minutes ago, Ty_Webb said:

As I think about it, I think that with the old rules, you had an incentive to ask about a potential penalty when you finished your round. If you didn't and it came up you'd get DQ'd or another 2 strokes. Now, you have no such incentive because why bring it up?

Yes… I've mentioned this one more than a few times. Yet another way ignorance is encouraged.

44 minutes ago, Ty_Webb said:

What really annoys me about this change is it seems like it's there purely because the perception is that Lexi Thompson got 4 penalty strokes for moving her ball an inch. I have never marked a ball and picked it up without knowing where I had to put it to put it back where I picked it up from. The fact that she wasn't able to do that and that has apparently resulted in this rule change makes my blood boil.

Yep.

Victim culture.

Erik J. Barzeski β€” β›³Β I knock a ball. It goes in a gopher hole. πŸŒπŸΌβ€β™‚οΈ
Director of InstructionΒ Golf EvolutionΒ β€’Β Owner,Β The Sand Trap .comΒ β€’Β Author,Β Lowest Score Wins
Golf DigestΒ "Best Young Teachers in America" 2016-17Β &Β "Best in State" 2017-20Β β€’ WNY Section PGA Teacher of the Year 2019Β :edel:Β :true_linkswear:

Check Out:Β New TopicsΒ |Β TST BlogΒ |Β Golf TermsΒ |Β Instructional ContentΒ |Β AnalyzrΒ |Β LSWΒ | Instructional Droplets

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

  • Administrator

BTW, it stands to be said that though this discussion is lengthy, and though I'm passionate about it as well,Β I realize that this type of situation is unlikely to occur often. This is a bit of a "rules geek" conversation.

I know all that, and admit it freely.

But, this is one of the two changes to the Rules in 2019 that I hate the most. So that's why I talk about it.

Erik J. Barzeski β€” β›³Β I knock a ball. It goes in a gopher hole. πŸŒπŸΌβ€β™‚οΈ
Director of InstructionΒ Golf EvolutionΒ β€’Β Owner,Β The Sand Trap .comΒ β€’Β Author,Β Lowest Score Wins
Golf DigestΒ "Best Young Teachers in America" 2016-17Β &Β "Best in State" 2017-20Β β€’ WNY Section PGA Teacher of the Year 2019Β :edel:Β :true_linkswear:

Check Out:Β New TopicsΒ |Β TST BlogΒ |Β Golf TermsΒ |Β Instructional ContentΒ |Β AnalyzrΒ |Β LSWΒ | Instructional Droplets

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

36 minutes ago, iacas said:

But, this is one of the two changes to the Rules in 2019 that I hate the most.

Understood. But what are places like this for if not to discuss the esoteric stuff? Out of curiosity what’s the other?

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Just now, Ty_Webb said:

Understood. But what are places like this for if not to discuss the esoteric stuff? Out of curiosity what’s the other?

The flagstick!Β πŸ˜„

"Age improves with wine."
Β 
Wishon 919THI 11*
Wishon 925HL 4w
Wishon 335HL 3h & 4h
Wishon 755pc 5i, 6i, 7i, 8i & 9i
Tad Moore 485 PW
Callaway X 54*
Ping G2 Anser C
Callaway SuperSoft
Titleist StaDry
Kangaroo Hillcrest AB

  • Administrator
7 minutes ago, Asheville said:

The flagstick!Β πŸ˜„

Yep.

Erik J. Barzeski β€” β›³Β I knock a ball. It goes in a gopher hole. πŸŒπŸΌβ€β™‚οΈ
Director of InstructionΒ Golf EvolutionΒ β€’Β Owner,Β The Sand Trap .comΒ β€’Β Author,Β Lowest Score Wins
Golf DigestΒ "Best Young Teachers in America" 2016-17Β &Β "Best in State" 2017-20Β β€’ WNY Section PGA Teacher of the Year 2019Β :edel:Β :true_linkswear:

Check Out:Β New TopicsΒ |Β TST BlogΒ |Β Golf TermsΒ |Β Instructional ContentΒ |Β AnalyzrΒ |Β LSWΒ | Instructional Droplets

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

  • Administrator
8 minutes ago, NM Golf said:

Well you can betΒ she won't to learn the rules now, starting next year she can just feign ignorance and everything will be okay. Although in this case I believe she would still have been DQed, correct?

Because the ball was OB, she was DQed, and would have been had the facts come to light after she had signed her scorecard.

But let's imagine her mom kicked her ball from a nestled lie in the roots of a tree in amongst a clump of thick trees 20 feet toward the fairwayΒ where she had a pretty clear shot. The player is made aware of the kicking - but not that it may be a penalty - and plays the ball as it lies without thinking that there was anything wrong.

Bam, two strokes ONLY, despite the fact that she knew that her ball at rest had been moved and the Rules state that you're responsible for knowing the Rules and attesting to the correct score.

This year, that would still be two plus the additional two for not including the penalty strokes. Next year, just the two strokes. 😞

Β 

Erik J. Barzeski β€” β›³Β I knock a ball. It goes in a gopher hole. πŸŒπŸΌβ€β™‚οΈ
Director of InstructionΒ Golf EvolutionΒ β€’Β Owner,Β The Sand Trap .comΒ β€’Β Author,Β Lowest Score Wins
Golf DigestΒ "Best Young Teachers in America" 2016-17Β &Β "Best in State" 2017-20Β β€’ WNY Section PGA Teacher of the Year 2019Β :edel:Β :true_linkswear:

Check Out:Β New TopicsΒ |Β TST BlogΒ |Β Golf TermsΒ |Β Instructional ContentΒ |Β AnalyzrΒ |Β LSWΒ | Instructional Droplets

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

My biggest pet peeve at my club is players participating in competition and not knowing the rules. I am constantly correcting the players in my group but I also know that no one is policing a lot of the groups in the competition. In the vast majority of cases they are certainly not trying to gain an advantageΒ but that is beside the point. I play by the rules and so should they.

When I was Golf Chairman I would direct the pro staff to make sure that someone in each foursome had a a rudimentary knowledge of the rules because they know the serious players from the causal golfers and they should never put four casual golfers together in a competition. That isn't done anymore and all I can do is shake my head when I scan the tee times and see four knuckleheads in a foursome.Β 

Bill M

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

  • 1 month later...

I do not think the phrasing of the answers areΒ fair to the topic. TheyΒ rival,Β β€œdo you still beat your wife?”. Β  I believe the changes are beneficial for players who are new or less experienced. Too often Rule Nazi’sΒ run players away from the game. Β Let them love the game first and they will grow to support everything else that goes with it.Β 


  • Administrator
2 minutes ago, Jcomninaki said:

I do not think the phrasing of the answers areΒ fair to the topic. TheyΒ rival,Β β€œdo you still beat your wife?”. Β  I believe the changes are beneficial for players who are new or less experienced. Too often Rule Nazi’sΒ run players away from the game. Β Let them love the game first and they will grow to support everything else that goes with it.Β 

I don't think new players really ever get that involved in rules situations. New players are just out hitting a ball around. They're not playing in all that many competitions.

Rules Nazis? Do you mean people who play by the Rules? Again, one of my favorite quotes:

E0882544-BD40-47AF-B365-06A77A2DF667.jpeg

  • Like 1

Erik J. Barzeski β€” β›³Β I knock a ball. It goes in a gopher hole. πŸŒπŸΌβ€β™‚οΈ
Director of InstructionΒ Golf EvolutionΒ β€’Β Owner,Β The Sand Trap .comΒ β€’Β Author,Β Lowest Score Wins
Golf DigestΒ "Best Young Teachers in America" 2016-17Β &Β "Best in State" 2017-20Β β€’ WNY Section PGA Teacher of the Year 2019Β :edel:Β :true_linkswear:

Check Out:Β New TopicsΒ |Β TST BlogΒ |Β Golf TermsΒ |Β Instructional ContentΒ |Β AnalyzrΒ |Β LSWΒ | Instructional Droplets

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

  • Moderator
On 10/16/2018 at 10:53 PM, Vinsk said:

I have to agree with @iacasΒ here. What I actually think should happen is that all players in a tournament should have to sign an agreement prior to play that includes the rules and that they understand and agree to abide by them. If they are in question of any rule, they have the right to call an official for clarification. Failure to do so will result in the appropriate penalty for said breach. With this information posted we can kiss any chance of back stopping to stop.

For comparison only, we physicians are required to complete CME (Continuing Medical Education) constantly along with Board Certification exam every 10 years. I don't see it being too much to ask that in order to maintain ones PGA card a player must take a rules exam annually as a requirement. Claiming ignorance as an excuse to not be penalized seems completely unjust.Β 

Exactly - I hate the 10yr recert. Β Good point, VinskΒ 

Driver:Β :callaway:Β Rogue STΒ Β / Β Woods:Β :tmade:Β Stealth 5W /Β Hybrid:Β :tmade:Β Stealth 25* /Β Irons: :ping:Β i500’s /Β Β Wedges:Β :edel:Β 54*, 58*;Β Putter:Β :scotty_cameron:Β Futura 5 Β Ball:Β image.pngΒ Vero X1

Β 

Β -Jonny

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

This rule reminds me of football and basketball where players get away with not playing by the rules.Β  There are times when football or basketball playersΒ might not know the rules and/or the refs don't call a foul, and likewise a player is not expected to callΒ a foul on themselves.Β  And in those gamesΒ nobodyΒ changes the score after the game...the refs just apologize for bad calls.Β Β 

Other rules should be changed to match the tour.Β  One would be the lost ball penalty because it can't be found despite knowing the ball is not out of play.Β  This rarely happens on tour with spotters. Plus, I also don't think tour players should get advice from their caddie to line-up putts.Β  That's an advantage the average golfer doesn't have, or allow some form of green reading DMD toΒ help everyone else..

AndΒ if the goal is to conform to tour rules, people should be walking vs. riding in carts.Β Β 


  • Administrator
36 minutes ago, Puttin4Dough said:

This rule reminds me of football and basketball where players get away with not playing by the rules.Β  There are times when football or basketball playersΒ might not know the rules and/or the refs don't call a foul, and likewise a player is not expected to callΒ a foul on themselves.Β  And in those gamesΒ nobodyΒ changes the score after the game...the refs just apologize for bad calls.

Okay, but that's not a good thing, IMO. Golf is not played with referees or umpires.

The rest of the post is off topic, so, my reply is in a spoiler, though really this should move to the topic here:

Spoiler
36 minutes ago, Puttin4Dough said:

One would be the lost ball penalty because it can't be found despite knowing the ball is not out of play.Β  This rarely happens on tour with spotters.

  • Why change a Rule based on 0.001% of golfers?
  • Does the new (2019) Local Rule for a ball OB/lost not suffice, here?
36 minutes ago, Puttin4Dough said:

Plus, I also don't think tour players should get advice from their caddie to line-up putts.

In 2019 the caddie can't align a player, but the caddie is part of their team, and I'm not even sure how you'd legislate against a caddie helping the player here.

36 minutes ago, Puttin4Dough said:

That's an advantage the average golfer doesn't have

Not necessarily. The average golfer also drives around in a cart.

36 minutes ago, Puttin4Dough said:

AndΒ if the goal is to conform to tour rules, people should be walking vs. riding in carts.Β Β 

Huh?Β That's not the goal.

Erik J. Barzeski β€” β›³Β I knock a ball. It goes in a gopher hole. πŸŒπŸΌβ€β™‚οΈ
Director of InstructionΒ Golf EvolutionΒ β€’Β Owner,Β The Sand Trap .comΒ β€’Β Author,Β Lowest Score Wins
Golf DigestΒ "Best Young Teachers in America" 2016-17Β &Β "Best in State" 2017-20Β β€’ WNY Section PGA Teacher of the Year 2019Β :edel:Β :true_linkswear:

Check Out:Β New TopicsΒ |Β TST BlogΒ |Β Golf TermsΒ |Β Instructional ContentΒ |Β AnalyzrΒ |Β LSWΒ | Instructional Droplets

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

23 minutes ago, iacas said:

Okay, but that's not a good thing, IMO. Golf is not played with referees or umpires.

The rest of the post is off topic, so, my reply is in a spoiler, though really this should move to the topic here:

Β  Reveal hidden contents
  • Why change a Rule based on 0.001% of golfers?
  • Does the new (2019) Local Rule for a ball OB/lost not suffice, here?

In 2019 the caddie can't align a player, but the caddie is part of their team, and I'm not even sure how you'd legislate against a caddie helping the player here.

Not necessarily. The average golfer also drives around in a cart.

Huh?Β That's not the goal.

Really not off-topic.Β  I'm pointing out thatΒ tour players have access to spotters and personal caddie's which could be viewed as an unfair advantageΒ compared to the average golfer.Β  I take a 2 stroke lost ball while the spotter finds their ball.Β  i miss a slight break on a green that they don't.Β  And caddies are like having a golf instructor during every round.Β Β Thus, the allowance for unintentional ruleΒ mishaps for the average golfer equal out some ofΒ theΒ advantages tour players enjoy.

Β 


  • Administrator
Just now, Puttin4Dough said:

Really not off-topic. I'm pointing out thatΒ tour players have access to spotters and personal caddie's which could be viewed as an unfair advantageΒ compared to the average golfer.

The topic is "Failure to Include and Unknown Penalty," so yes, it is off topic.

Erik J. Barzeski β€” β›³Β I knock a ball. It goes in a gopher hole. πŸŒπŸΌβ€β™‚οΈ
Director of InstructionΒ Golf EvolutionΒ β€’Β Owner,Β The Sand Trap .comΒ β€’Β Author,Β Lowest Score Wins
Golf DigestΒ "Best Young Teachers in America" 2016-17Β &Β "Best in State" 2017-20Β β€’ WNY Section PGA Teacher of the Year 2019Β :edel:Β :true_linkswear:

Check Out:Β New TopicsΒ |Β TST BlogΒ |Β Golf TermsΒ |Β Instructional ContentΒ |Β AnalyzrΒ |Β LSWΒ | Instructional Droplets

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

36 minutes ago, iacas said:

The topic is "Failure to Include and Unknown Penalty," so yes, it is off topic.

There's a reason the USGA adopted the rule...it's because the rules can become wildly obscure.Β  Plus, there are know-nothings whoΒ can affect another players score with incorrect interpretations.Β Β 

While you might think folks will cheat for their own advantage....I've played with folks in competitions that literally make up theΒ rules to cheat another player to their advantage.Β Β Case in point.Β Β I played in a tourney where my ball landed near a prickly bush.Β  I was told I had to play it despite getting impaled by thorns.Β  I told the OP that wrapping a towel around my thigh was legal,Β  he said it was not.Β  He knew better, but he was testing me to see if I knew the rules.Β  It goes both ways.


45 minutes ago, Puttin4Dough said:

Really not off-topic.Β  I'm pointing out thatΒ tour players have access to spotters and personal caddie's which could be viewed as an unfair advantageΒ compared to the average golfer.Β  I take a 2 stroke lost ball while the spotter finds their ball.Β  i miss a slight break on a green that they don't.Β  And caddies are like having a golf instructor during every round.Β Β Thus, the allowance for unintentional ruleΒ mishaps for the average golfer equal out some ofΒ theΒ advantages tour players enjoy.

Β 

Puttin4Dough... you are onto something!Β  For years, in casual rounds, not recording scores for GHIN, with my foursome doing the same, I have played by what I call "Gallery Rules".Β  Tour pros have trainers, caddies, spotters, nutritionists, spectators, spectators who kick their ball back in bounds, rules officials, TV cameras and marshals to help locate their slightly wayward ball that we, as common folk, usually lose.Β Β 

You know the scenario... you rip a drive down the left side, but not even into the trees.Β  And it disappears from the face of the earth.Β  Doesn't happen to the pros.Β  I say they have enough advantages that I should get some of them, too.

Hence, "Gallery Rules".Β  If my ball is lost where it should have been in plain sight, I drop another ball (unsponsored, with no freebies) where I fairly decide it would have been found. No penalty.Β Β 

Now, when I play in a tournament I don't do this, though I do hire 100-200 spectators to follow me.Β Β 

Β 

  • Like 1

Note:Β This thread is 2102 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic.Β Thank you!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • TST Partners

    PlayBetter
    TourStriker PlaneMate
    Golfer's Journal
    ShotScope
    The Stack System
    FitForGolf
    FlightScope Mevo
    Direct: Mevo, Mevo+, and Pro Package.

    Coupon Codes (save 10-20%): "IACAS" for Mevo/Stack/FitForGolf, "IACASPLUS" for Mevo+/Pro Package, and "THESANDTRAP" for ShotScope. 15% off TourStriker (no code).
  • Posts

    • Okay, I'm genuinely curious about this "biodegradable leather" trend in golf. Are we talking snake oil here? I mean, golf balls, clubs... they all end up in the water eventually. Is this just greenwashing, or is there actually a real environmental benefit? And honestly, does it even perform as well as traditional leather? I don't want to sacrifice distance for the planet, you know? Anyone with real-world experience with these eco-friendly golf goods? Spill the tea!
    • Wordle 1,282 5/6 ⬜⬜🟩⬜⬜ ⬜🟩🟩🟨⬜ ⬜🟩🟩⬜🟩 ⬜🟩🟩🟩🟩 🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
    • Wordle 1,282 4/6 🟨🟨⬜⬜⬜ ⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜ ⬜🟩🟩🟨⬜ 🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
    • Wordle 1,282 5/6 🟨⬜⬜⬜⬜ ⬜⬜🟩🟨⬜ ⬜🟩🟩⬜⬜ ⬜🟩🟩🟩🟩 🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
    • Wordle 1,282 3/6 ⬜🟩🟩⬜⬜ ⬜🟩🟩🟩⬜ 🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
Γ—
Γ—
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...