Jump to content
IGNORED

Jack vs. Tiger: Who's the Greatest Golfer?


sungho_kr

Greatest Golfer (GOAT)  

218 members have voted

  1. 1. Tiger or Jack: Who's the greatest golfer?

    • Tiger Woods is the man
      1629
    • Jack Nicklaus is my favorite
      817


Recommended Posts

[URL=http://fivethirtyeight.com/datalab/win-or-lose-at-the-pga-jordan-spieth-is-having-one-of-golfs-greatest-seasons/]http://fivethirtyeight.com/datalab/win-or-lose-at-the-pga-jordan-spieth-is-having-one-of-golfs-greatest-seasons/[/URL] Another perspective: I saw this article on 538 Sports about how Jordan Spieth is having one of the greatest golf seasons ever. It posted a graphic that ranked the best seasons in golf history. Of the Top 20, Jack has 8 and Tiger 7. However, Tiger holds the 1,2,4,5,6,8, and 17 spots while Jack has 3,7,9,10,11,13,16,20. Spieth's is ranked 12 using this methodology, which uses standard deviations above/below all tournament averages for the given year. A pretty common and useful statistical tool. Just something else to add to the fire...

Not sure I buy that Tiger and Jack own all of golf's top-10 seasons ever, and Nelson, Hogan, and Jones are all excluded (surely at least one of those three deserves a mention). But I appreciate an attempt at objective comparison.

Kevin

Titleist 910 D3 9.5* with ahina 72 X flex
Titleist 910F 13.5* with ahina 72 X flex
Adams Idea A12 Pro hybrid 18*; 23* with RIP S flex
Titleist 712 AP2 4-9 iron with KBS C-Taper, S+ flex
Titleist Vokey SM wedges 48*, 52*, 58*
Odyssey White Hot 2-ball mallet, center shaft, 34"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Not sure I buy that Tiger and Jack own all of golf's top-10 seasons ever, and Nelson, Hogan, and Jones are all excluded (surely at least one of those three deserves a mention).

But I appreciate an attempt at objective comparison.


I agree, but the lack of stats kept in those days makes a true comparison difficult. Surely Hogan in 1953 or Jones in 1930 should be on the list. That's why these GOAT talks in any sport always boil down to "my science is better than your science" in the end, IMO. That's cool, though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

While performance in major championships is not the only means of deciding the matter, it is important.

Woods has now played in 76 major championships (through the 2015 P.G.A. Championship). Here is his record compared to Nicklaus’s first 76:

Jack:
1st - 15
2nd - 15
3rd - 9
4-10 - 16

Tiger:
1st - 14
2nd - 6
3rd - 4
4-10 - 14

Link to comment
Share on other sites


  • 4 months later...
On 8/1/2015 at 7:34 AM, jbishop15 said:

I'm not trying to be rude here, but have you read any of the posts in this thread? A lot of the points you brought up have been discussed with a lot of depth.

Sounds like you were trying to be rude. Isn't Vasp entitled to have an opinion? 

Personally, I agree with him. I also think that Nicklaus is the GOAT. It's close, but not that close.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

  • Moderator
5 hours ago, Pendragon said:

Sounds like you were trying to be rude. Isn't Vasp entitled to have an opinion? 

Personally, I agree with him. I also think that Nicklaus is the GOAT. It's close, but not that close.

Not when they don't bother reading anything in the thread and rehash the same old stuff. We call it a "fly by post". jpbishop15 was correct in suggesting Vasp read the thread. He was not being rude.

 

Scott

Titleist, Edel, Scotty Cameron Putter, Snell - AimPoint - Evolvr - MirrorVision

My Swing Thread

boogielicious - Adjective describing the perfect surf wave

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I am going with neither one was the best.or GOAT.  I am making them both a GOTE, which is greatest of their era, since they did not play each other in head to head competition. I have probably posted this opinion many times before. :beer:

In My Bag:
A whole bunch of Tour Edge golf stuff...... :beer:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

  • Moderator
39 minutes ago, Patch said:

I am going with neither one was the best.or GOAT.  I am making them both a GOTE, which is greatest of their era, since they did not play each other in head to head competition. I have probably posted this opinion many times before. :beer:

GOTE with goatee

5671602b120cd_tigergoatee.jpg.ab1a044895

tiger goatee.jpg

tiger goatee.jpg

Scott

Titleist, Edel, Scotty Cameron Putter, Snell - AimPoint - Evolvr - MirrorVision

My Swing Thread

boogielicious - Adjective describing the perfect surf wave

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

7 hours ago, Pendragon said:

Sounds like you were trying to be rude. Isn't Vasp entitled to have an opinion? 

Personally, I agree with him. I also think that Nicklaus is the GOAT. It's close, but not that close.

Lol, okay. Enjoy the thread.

Hunter Bishop

"i was an aspirant once of becoming a flamenco guitarist, but i had an accident with my fingers"

My Bag

Titleist TSI3 | TaylorMade Sim 2 Max 3 Wood | 5 Wood | Edel 3-PW | 52° | 60° | Blade Putter

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Scoring average against the fields of the day could be a good indicator coupled with wins.This way we see overall play and ability to close.

Note: I do not answer direct questions or points raised against my untested and unproven theories, have no history of teaching anyone, and post essentially the same nonsense in everyone's Member Swing threads.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


  • Moderator
8 minutes ago, collapse said:

Scoring average against the fields of the day could be a good indicator coupled with wins.This way we see overall play and ability to close.

That data has been presented in this thread. It does not favor Jack.

Scott

Titleist, Edel, Scotty Cameron Putter, Snell - AimPoint - Evolvr - MirrorVision

My Swing Thread

boogielicious - Adjective describing the perfect surf wave

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Just now, boogielicious said:

That data has been presented in this thread. It does not favor Jack.

Then TW is the best.

Note: I do not answer direct questions or points raised against my untested and unproven theories, have no history of teaching anyone, and post essentially the same nonsense in everyone's Member Swing threads.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Having been away from this board for several months, it is good to see that the debate rages on - as well as the debate about the debate.

Seeing this thread as the 2nd thread at the top of the board is a familiar & welcoming site.

Players play, tough players win!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

  • Moderator

 

STOP THE PRESSES

Brandel Chamblee says Woods is the greatest of all time. Shaking my head... wait... what? Full program to be broadcasted on the 30th. Holiday doldrums ratings grab?

Video, or it didn't happen? Here:

http://www.golfchannel.com/media/golf-central-december-16-2015/

Steve

Kill slow play. Allow walking. Reduce ineffective golf instruction. Use environmentally friendly course maintenance.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Just thinking here before I go for my morning walk in 25 degree weather. ( move over coffee, as this is job for alcohol)

Has anyone taken the time to take all tournaments won during their different eras of golf and put the same dollar value on each of their's and their competition wins? Probably wouldn't mean anything other than adding fuel to the discussion. 

In My Bag:
A whole bunch of Tour Edge golf stuff...... :beer:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Well said...no inconsistencies.

http://www.golfchannel.com/media/chamblee-woods-greatest-player-all-time/

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Note: I do not answer direct questions or points raised against my untested and unproven theories, have no history of teaching anyone, and post essentially the same nonsense in everyone's Member Swing threads.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


 

 

       Is it truly able to be determined ??     both had their prime in different era's of golf  with different equipment , courses ...compitition ..to me Jack was the best in some but Tiger was the best at some events also ... i like to remember both Jack and Tiger as playing tournament golf better than any other players in the last 50 years 

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites


13 hours ago, Birdiechaser said:

 

 

       Is it truly able to be determined ??     both had their prime in different era's of golf  with different equipment , courses ...compitition ..to me Jack was the best in some but Tiger was the best at some events also ... i like to remember both Jack and Tiger as playing tournament golf better than any other players in the last 50 years 

Determined on some kind of objective basis?  Of course not.

But people have been comparing athletes as long as athletics have been with us.  And just because players played indifferent eras doesn't mean there cannot be an interesting and useful discussion.  

For example, I put Tiger on top because he dominated professional golf for a 15 year period (which, while I would love it if he had been able to maintain longer is still plenty long enough for me to check the longevity box) to an extent that very few players, including Jack, has ever done even for a season or two.  Between 1996 and 2009 Tiger was clearly not only the best player but the best player by a large margin for all but 2 years (1998, and 2004 - I'm giving him 2008, although some might argue).  Jack,on the other hand, was always one of the top 3-4 players for 25 years, but if you look at the actual years, he was the best player in only a handful of years.  And even in the years when he was the best player he was nowhere near as dominant as Tiger was.  

Tiger's peak was way higher than Jack's, while Jack's peak lasted longer. Those who value longevity over brilliance will favor Jack.  Those who favor brilliance over longevity will favor Tiger.  

 

Welcome to the Board!

Edited by turtleback
to add some longwindedness

But then again, what the hell do I know?

Rich - in name only

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • TST Partners

    TourStriker PlaneMate
    Golfer's Journal
    ShotScope
    The Stack System
    FlightScope Mevo
    Direct: Mevo, Mevo+, and Pro Package.

    Coupon Codes (save 10-15%): "IACAS" for Mevo/Stack, "IACASPLUS" for Mevo+/Pro Package, and "THESANDTRAP" for ShotScope.
  • Popular Now

  • Posts

    • It’s going to change but your basic setup feel should be about the same. Your body kind of adjusts to length and lie angle of the club. You’ll want to pay attention more to ball position as you change clubs more than how bent over you are. I understood what you meant from what your wrote.
    • Oh I probably was thinking the wrong thing or the wrong way when I typed the golf swing was more of a body swing (in my mind).  The in my mind part probably should have said in my opinion or based on what I have read.  Just meant the body needs to be involved more than the hands and swinging the arms while the core remains still.
    • The answer to this question is a very small change in impact can cause a BIG impact in direction. This is with the driver, but its similar with the irons... How much does an open or closed clubface affect your drives? | RoboTest Want to hit more fairways? The latest edition of GOLF's RoboTest highlights the importance of driver face angle. For a driver, 1 degree of clubface open or shut causes 10 yards of left or right. When you think the rate of closure for a golf club, how fast the club face goes from open (top of the golf swing) to square (at impact), 1 degree is a small quantity.  This means, when you are looking at video of your swing, you can see the exact same swing, but present the clubface in two widely separate positions. More so if you have swing faults. You can make the same backswing, but not get your weight forward well and hit a fat shot. You then react to this, try not to fat it so you thin it. Maybe the timing is off on the extension part of the downswing and you thin it slightly. Also, certain swing movements cause the wrists to flip at impact. The intent is still to hit the ball with the club. So your hands are going to adjust to find the ball. The more they have to adjust, the more difficult it is to repeat. Nope, it is way less mental than physical. If we could all think our way to a better swing, we would all be PGA tour players.  #GOLF IS HARD!  Beginners have repeatable swings, just bad repeatable swing. We all just need to make repeatable better swings.  The golf swing is a battle of making movements that allow the club to do good things. You results are from a bad swing that has a wider range of outcomes. Your outcomes are probably the following. Way more thins, fats, skulls than most. You hardly see PGA Tour players fat, skull or thin a shot.  The first principle of golf is FEEL IS NOT REAL. Meaning, we can feel things in the golf swing, yet it produces results or shows on video as something else.  You just set up to the ball. The club has a different length, so you need to adjust. For most your arms extend more out as you have a longer club. You also bend over less for longer clubs. It is just something you get used to. If you make a fist and stick your thumb out. You want that width from the butt end of the club and your belt buckle. Now, if you taller or shorter than most, then you may need to adjust the length of your clubs.    
    • At address? I think so. Downswing and through? IDK. I doubt if a whole lot of golfers, if any at all, deliberately think "I have a 9-iron so I need to bend half an inch more through the downswing compared to my 8 iron". 
    • Wordle 1,054 X/6 ⬜⬜🟩⬜⬜ ⬜⬜🟩⬜⬜ ⬜⬜🟩🟨⬜ 🟨⬜🟩⬜⬜ ⬜⬜🟩⬜🟩 ⬜⬜🟩🟨🟩 My third failure..
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...