• Announcements

    • iacas

      Introducing TST "Clubs!"   08/28/2017

      No, we're not getting into the equipment business, but we do have "clubs" here on TST now. Groups. Check them out here:
Sign in to follow this  
newtogolf

Should a great instructor also be a great golfer?

0  

  1. 1. Would you take lessons from an instructor that isn't a great golfer?

    • Yes
      27
    • No
      14


Recommended Posts

newtogolf    957

Sean Foley is not known for his golf game but he's coaching some of the best players on Tour.  Would you be comfortable taking lessons from an instructor that isn't at least a low single digits or scratch golfer?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Sign up (or log in) today! It's free (and you won't see this ad anymore)!

Sign up (or log in) today! It's free (and you won't see this ad anymore)!

Yukari    90
Those who can do. Those who can't teach.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Patch    317

Rather an instructor played to a low hdcp or not is not important to me. A great instructor to me is some one who can add to all the good things the golfer already has, and make that golfer better. For amateurs,  an instructor who also knows how a golf club works would be good thing. A qualified swing guru, that's also club builder is a great combination.

Several years ago, my family, as a birthday present, gave me 5 lessons at Butch Harmon's School of Golf. His building was just down the street from our home and the gift also included a round of golf at Rio Secco, so it was a good deal. No, I never even saw Harmon, but the instructor assigned to me was pretty good. I told him I wanted all 5 lesson applied to my short game from 100 yards out. He agreed, and that's all we worked on. To me he was a good instructor for letting me pick the type of instruction I wanted. He told me he was new to golf instruction and was a 7 hdcp. More importantly he helped my short game score quite a bit.

My long game improve after only one session with a $25 an hour, no name  range pro. He gave me just one swing thought that eventually saved me close to 5 strokes, on average, off the tee, and on my longer approach shots. I was the only one who showed up for a group instruction. I got the hour to myself. When it came time to settle up he only wanted the original $25 agreed on at sign up. He received much more.  Unfortunately, since business was not so good for him, he moved on to another course.  In his office was proof he had played in 4 US Opens, so he was obviously a low hdcp.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

PJCdude    27
I couldn't tell you as much in golf since I am a high handicapper and have not taken any lessons (yet), but as a music teacher I'll tell you that you need to be somewhat proficient with reasonable success at what you are teaching. The main reason is modeling. If you have piss poor technique, it is impossible to model correctly. Now you can use video of others, but barring any injury or disability you should be able to perform what you are asking your student to do. This will also hurt your credibility and harm your student's chances of performing properly. If they see their instructor struggling with a specific action, how can they expect themselves to be successful? Again, I can't speak to this so much as far as golf but I feel like the same principles apply.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

nevets88    805

I wonder about this hypothetical/thought experiment...

Take two people, both very smart, academic/book smart and street/life/common sense/emotional intelligence smart. One is a 2.5 handicap, the other, not much of an athlete, but plays golf.

Both audit let's say 2,500 lessons given by a mix of say 5 different instructors who really know what they are doing. Both have read up in everything instruction wise - TGM, MORAD, SnT, 5SK, etc...

Having never instructed golf before, both give lessons to all sorts of players, let's say 500 lessons, under the tutelage of above instructors.

Conclusions?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

MEfree    34

I don't think someone has to be a great player to be a great instructor (and not all great players make good instructors), but, unless a guy has some physical limitations, I would be skeptical taking lessons from a bad golfer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

newtogolf    957

I prefer an instructor be a good golfer, scratch or better.  I don't know what Foley's handicap is but he might be the exception.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

nevets88    805

Meant to post this here first, but posted in the other thread.

I wonder about this hypothetical/thought experiment...

Take two people, both very smart, academic/book smart and street/life/common sense/emotional intelligence smart. One is a 2.5 handicap, the other, not much of an athlete, but plays golf.

Both audit let's say 2,500 lessons given by a mix of say 5 different instructors who really know what they are doing. Both have read up in everything instruction wise - TGM, MORAD, SnT, 5SK, etc...

Having never instructed golf before, both give lessons to all sorts of players, let's say 500 lessons, under the tutelage of above instructors.

Conclusions?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

MEfree    34

Meant to post this here first, but posted in the other thread.

I wonder about this hypothetical/thought experiment...

Take two people, both very smart, academic/book smart and street/life/common sense/emotional intelligence smart. One is a 2.5 handicap, the other, not much of an athlete, but plays golf.

Both audit let's say 2,500 lessons given by a mix of say 5 different instructors who really know what they are doing. Both have read up in everything instruction wise - TGM, MORAD, SnT, 5SK, etc...

Having never instructed golf before, both give lessons to all sorts of players, let's say 500 lessons, under the tutelage of above instructors.

Conclusions?

Most guys who are a 2.5 index have played a lot of golf, been exposed to golf instruction and many would have informally coached friends on the range even if they are not professional instructors.  Auditing 2,500 lessons- I doubt many guys have done that.

Even if you had two guys do exactly as you propose, it would still be anecdotal as there would be too many individual factors that might make one a good teacher over the other.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

David in FL    1,521

Great player....not necessarily.  Good player, absolutely.  An instructor needs to have a certain degree of credibility, and "do as I say, even though I can't do it myself", just isn't going to get it.  He needs to at least be a solid ball-striker himself.  That means somewhere sub-3 at least.  Anything higher is just too inconsistent......

.....ask me how I know. :8)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Shindig    250
I wonder what fraction of his career Harvey Penick could break 80. I bet there was some overlap in the time where he couldn't but still taught Tom Kite.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Jeremie Boop    286

Here's the deal, if they can spot the swing flaws and give the correct fixes and adjustments what does their handicap have to do with anything? I don't expect that the instructor/pro hit balls for me to see, I expect that person to get me to hit the ball better. If I'm hitting the ball better at the end of the day that's all that matters.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

nevets88    805

OK, let's say for my 2,500K hypothetical, you take 2 guys who haven't played a lick of golf. They audit and teach, but one is a <5 handicap and the other can't break 80.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

David in FL    1,521
I wonder what fraction of his career Harvey Penick could break 80. I bet there was some overlap in the time where he couldn't but still taught Tom Kite.

Completely different when someone's playing ability has eroded simply because of age, as opposed to the guy who wants to teach others but can't break 80 himself.

I believe it was Lee Trevino that said that he'd never take a lesson from someone who couldn't beat him.  I think that's extreme when applied to a highly skilled tour pro, but I'd absolutely apply it myself.....  I know how poorly I strike the ball!  I want someone that I know can strike it consistently better than me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

vangator    114
A good golfer may be a lousy teacher due to verbal skills etc. But I think a good teacher should be a good golfer (or at least should have been in the past, such as Harvey Pennick). If they are a good teacher, they should be able to translate that into a good game for themselves. Many years ago I went to a golf instructor for lessons. He had his own show on local TV. I thought I would get him (the head honcho). I guess he had a staff of minions. I got a kid that was going to give the lessons. The first question I asked the kid was "what do you normally shoot?" He said, "about 85." I said "thanks, but no thanks." I consistently shot in the 70's. Why would I take the chance of getting lessons from someone I was better than? He may have helped me with some mechanics etc, but for my money I wanted an expert. The kid who shot 85 would be better suited for cutting his teeth with a bunch of noobs. Tiger Woods and others use Shawn Foley as their intructor. I always wondered how good he is. He looks more like a Biology teacher. :) https://sp1.yimg.com/ib/th?id=HN.608056005118723229&pid;=15.1&P;=0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

billchao    477
I voted no. I care more about my instructor's ability to teach than his or her ability to play. They should be good enough to demonstrate what they are teaching, but being able to play at a tour level is unnecessary.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2017 TST Partners

    Talamore Golf Resort
    PING Golf
    FlightScope Mevo
    Mission Belt
    Snell Golf
    Frogger Golf
    PitchFix USA
  • Posts

    • Gotcha. Thanks. That's a possibility too. I don't feel like I am hanging back but as you know feel ain't real.  Most likely my problem is a combination of things (maybe ball too far back combined with hanging back?). This started happening out of the blue and has been going on for about 2 weeks (5-6 rounds), and even with range work i have not been able to shake it off... yet! Thank you all for the suggestions. I'll try to double check them one at a time until I can tell for sure whether my not implementing them is the culprit. It shouldn't be too hard to recover from this, but it sure is annoying...
    • https://www.gamegolf.com/player/JonMa1/round/1859679?hole_id=34840967 Short and mid iron approaches were pretty good. Pitches, chips were fine. I just had a rough time controlling the driver until the 13th today. Also had issues topping some 5i and 4i shots though I did hit a couple nice 4i shots. Putting was pretty poor today. I'm getting acceptable distance from my driver since having the shaft shortened and contact seems better. Unfortunately, controlling the club face continues to be a challenge. Excessive penalties have been the theme for 2017. Lowering my handicap from longer courses will be next to impossible if I don't improve this part of my game.
    • I'm surprised he didn't at least ponder if there was a rule on that. I didn't know but had it happened to me I definitely would've asked my partner or someone there, 'hey is there a rule about this?' Certainly shows how it pays to know the rules. 
    • At 63 I have all the same challenges others have noted. In addition, poorer eyesight has been a new challenge. I never had to play with glasses from age 10 to late 40's and then quit golf. Now at 63 and back playing golf, just seeing the ball clearly at address has been a significant issue for me. And of course corrective lenses that work at address aren't right for reading or distance vision. Anyone else? I'm afraid between poorer vision and all the senior physical challenges, my days of consistently finding the sweet spot on my clubs are probably over. Game improvement clubs here I (reluctantly) come...
    •  I bought one. I gave a review somewhere here. Anyway, short version: i wasn't real impressed with it. Not to mention it looks like an Alien Sandwedge from days back. It's rather embarrassing to have in the bag. Playability wise it does help with basic green side bunkers but without real options for adjustments for wanting different shot types. I actually decided to watch @mvmac's bunker post again and got a tip from him as well which had me doing much better with my 56* Ping Glide 2.0. it didn't give me any good feedback on tight lies from turf. As usual it's more about proper technique so the club now sits in my closet.
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Blog Entries

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Dresilved
      Dresilved
      (52 years old)
    2. kpetrina
      kpetrina
      (25 years old)
    3. Luana
      Luana
      (39 years old)
  • Get Great Gear with Amazon